误报，是指病毒防治产品将正常文件报为含有病毒的文件，或将正常操作误报为病毒行为。误报的危害有很多种：误报系统文件可能导致系统崩溃，误报银行或者证券软件可能会妨碍正常的交易操作导致经济财产损失，误报桌面软件可能导致相关软件无法使用等。
PCSL误报测试：大中华地区反病毒软件
PCSL大中华区反病毒软件误报测试（2011年第一期）
PCSecurityLabs
官方网站：http://www.pcsecuritylabs.net/
目录
1.测试简介及最新亮点
2.测试样本及认证标准
3.参测厂商及送测产品
4.详细测试数据
5.认证
6.免责声明
1.测试简介及最新亮点
误报，是指病毒防治产品将正常文件报为含有病毒的文件，或将正常操作误报为病毒行为。误报的危害有很多种：误报系统文件可能导致系统崩溃，误报银行或者证券软件可能会妨碍正常的交易操作导致经济财产损失，误报桌面软件可能导致相关软件无法使用等。
本次误报测试有以下特点：
A．测试样本涵盖新增的主流软件及网民必备软件。
B．测试样本增加了对台湾地区主流软件，特别是网银及证券软件的覆盖。
C．测试采取静态误报测试加动态误报测试的方式，除了对干净文件库进行了扫描之外，另随机抽取了30个主流软件进行安装验证动态误报。
D．PCSL即将推出的2011年第一期大中华区流行样本测试和全方位安全软件测试将引用本地误报测试的相关数据。
PCSL误报测试：静态误报文件列表
2.测试样本及认证标准
本次测试涵盖2010年下半年大中华区（包括中国大陆、港澳和台湾地区）新增的主流软件及网民必备软件。由于本次软件使用的样本库比较大，在此只列出反病毒软件误报的干净文件及来源：
静态误报文件列表：
PCSL误报测试：动态误报文件列表
动态误报文件列表：
BitComet比特彗星测试版20110111
CITIC B2C PayGate
CNTV-CBox网络电视客户端-2.0.0.1
Opera11.01-11.1.1164.0
pps影音正式版-2.7.0.1208
PPTV网络电视-2.7.0.0031
QQ旋风3.0-3.0.672.402
QQ浏览器5-5.0.6648.400
WinRAR4.00beta3中文版
乐视网络电视-4.8.0.1
人人桌面2.3
傲游3
兆丰证券旺得福-3.1.6.0
光大银行阳光网盾驱动
华南期货F1下单-0.53.0.0
台湾土地银行安控元件-1.0.0.0
国泰期货-8.2010.430.1
广发证券VIP快速交易版V6.01
招商证券财富版V9.02
搜狗高速浏览器-2.2.0.1713
有道词典4.0-4.0.22.5570
永丰金证券致富快手-1.0.0.1
美图秀秀2.5.7-2.5.7.1000
股市大亨-3.1.6.0
腾讯QQ2011-1.60.2012.192
豌豆荚手机精灵1.8-1.8.121.565
迅雷7-7.1.4.2112
金长江网上交易汇智版8.3
阿里旺旺2010正式版SP1-1.0.0.1
鲁大师-2.76.11.103
注：
静态误报测试：
PCSL用待测软件扫描干净文件样本库，测试待测软件是否有误杀
动态误报测试：
PCSL在待测软件监控启用的情况下安装30个常用软件，测试待测软件是否拦截正常软件的安装。
认证标准：
总误报合计小于等于2个，获得月度五星认证
总误报合计为3或者4个，获得月度四星认证
总误报合计为5或6个，获得月度三星认证
PCSL误报测试：参测厂商及送测产品
3. 参测厂商及送测产品
33款产品
|
参测厂商 |
待测产品 |
|
Antiy（安天） |
|
|
ArcaBit |
ArcaBit System Protection |
|
AVAST |
|
|
AVG |
|
|
AVIRA |
|
|
BitDefender |
|
|
COMODO |
|
|
Coranti |
Coranti 2010 |
|
Dr.WEB(道特韦伯) |
|
|
Emsisoft |
Emsisoft Anti Malware 5.0 |
|
ESET |
|
|
Filseclab（费尔安全实验室） |
|
|
F-Secure |
|
|
G DATA(歌德塔) |
|
|
IKARUS |
IKARUS Virus Utilities |
|
Jiangmin（江民） |
|
|
Kaspersky（卡巴斯基） |
|
|
Kingsoft（金山） |
|
|
McAfee（迈克菲） |
|
|
Micro World（麦克沃德) |
|
|
Microsoft（微软） |
|
|
NETGATE |
|
|
Panda（熊猫安全） |
|
|
Qihoo（奇虎） |
|
|
Quick Heal |
|
|
Rising（瑞星） |
|
|
SOPHOS |
|
|
Sunbelt |
|
|
Symantec（赛门铁克） |
|
|
Trend Micro（趋势科技） |
|
|
TrustPort |
TrustPort PC Security 2010 |
|
VBA32 |
|
|
Zillya |
Zillya! Antivirus |
注：待测软件病毒库冻结时间为2011年1月20日
PCSL误报测试：详细测试数据
4. 详细测试数据
|
厂商 |
误报（黄底为静态误报，红底为动态误报） |
总误报数 |
|
Antiy |
0f38d469e473c2c1953a60b31839a6d4 |
静态误报9，动态误报0，总误报9 |
|
1ae330727911ffd5f89e7ddd63ed99c6 | ||
|
2be0902045ec835e8b2d1b7dbcb540a3 | ||
|
9e47c1abe702fd2597cb15ab4fd71f55 | ||
|
653b3c557330035491672db5645d3efd | ||
|
b6cbad8c6f9679cd3329dce77f542cd6 | ||
|
c393ef8f7f5bf8c5cf7b8001e6a2cdff | ||
|
e69a8d71cec13827cccbe5fb201bb070 | ||
|
ef39c8f91d595f51514f3e5564625ddb | ||
|
ArcaBit |
1ae330727911ffd5f89e7ddd63ed99c6 |
静态误报5，动态误报1，总误报6 |
|
9e47c1abe702fd2597cb15ab4fd71f55 | ||
|
80eef40b16ff7458c9ba9850f128f86f | ||
|
77477bb73cbe07eac9f1cd439531b628 | ||
|
c031b5d4b40caa9e4cbb6c280d8f82de | ||
|
WinRAR4.00beta3中文版 | ||
|
AVAST |
42d4999c4848911e6d6bfad4a886e993 |
静态误报7，动态误报0，总误报7 |
|
70cb9583b40efbe50baee699d48ac88d | ||
|
80eef40b16ff7458c9ba9850f128f86f | ||
|
526d3af37815854b45c3968e0a1087f0 | ||
|
552f404a418073a4fdbe0d05ed04378d | ||
|
e69a8d71cec13827cccbe5fb201bb070 | ||
|
ef39c8f91d595f51514f3e5564625ddb | ||
|
AVG |
0f38d469e473c2c1953a60b31839a6d4 |
静态误报5，动态误报0，总误报5 |
|
9e47c1abe702fd2597cb15ab4fd71f55 | ||
|
42d4999c4848911e6d6bfad4a886e993 | ||
|
77477bb73cbe07eac9f1cd439531b628 | ||
|
ef39c8f91d595f51514f3e5564625ddb | ||
|
Avira |
0efc2cd726bc566415a74b4e3d2d1867 |
静态误报21，动态误报0，总误报21 |
|
1ae330727911ffd5f89e7ddd63ed99c6 | ||
|
2be0902045ec835e8b2d1b7dbcb540a3 | ||
|
3a34bdb68614160e8be63c114fd42c75 | ||
|
6d64483024226ec3e68a8ca63256848e | ||
|
8b9664c8a1e123921f6673c6e08784e2 | ||
|
09a58fecd1138e6bb5bc22be0a609953 | ||
|
9e47c1abe702fd2597cb15ab4fd71f55 | ||
|
11ca0eac890eb6338a31cfaa97db95c6 | ||
|
59d8a1274b711d1626dd23011afb68b4 | ||
|
80eef40b16ff7458c9ba9850f128f86f | ||
|
653b3c557330035491672db5645d3efd | ||
|
677a5528d2783e640e459fcfd7346e3e | ||
|
9843f3c120b327f67ad082d0d0ab1688 | ||
|
77477bb73cbe07eac9f1cd439531b628 | ||
|
b6cbad8c6f9679cd3329dce77f542cd6 | ||
|
c031b5d4b40caa9e4cbb6c280d8f82de | ||
|
d6054fe17044e6eed44e0dbfe808a2a2 | ||
|
dcdad352187b6e283bd559f75524a8af | ||
|
ebb634d5de705e31751cbbc1b0eb9f64 | ||
|
f7c2b3c3b7cfd2a0c24bc62449b36e19 | ||
|
BitDefender |
|
静态误报0，动态误报0，总误报0 |
|
COMODO |
0f38d469e473c2c1953a60b31839a6d4 |
静态误报13，动态误报5，总误报18 |
|
1ae330727911ffd5f89e7ddd63ed99c6 | ||
|
09a58fecd1138e6bb5bc22be0a609953 | ||
|
29c72195850835532fa188b605b884b5 | ||
|
80eef40b16ff7458c9ba9850f128f86f | ||
|
653b3c557330035491672db5645d3efd | ||
|
677a5528d2783e640e459fcfd7346e3e | ||
|
77477bb73cbe07eac9f1cd439531b628 | ||
|
b6cbad8c6f9679cd3329dce77f542cd6 | ||
|
c031b5d4b40caa9e4cbb6c280d8f82de | ||
|
e69a8d71cec13827cccbe5fb201bb070 | ||
|
ebb634d5de705e31751cbbc1b0eb9f64 | ||
|
ef39c8f91d595f51514f3e5564625ddb | ||
|
光大银行阳光网盾驱动 | ||
|
华南期货F1下单-0.53.0.0 | ||
|
招商证券财富版V9.02 | ||
|
股市大亨-3.1.6.0 | ||
|
金长江网上交易汇智版8.3 | ||
|
Coranti |
0f38d469e473c2c1953a60b31839a6d4 |
静态误报18，动态误报3，总误报21 |
|
2be0902045ec835e8b2d1b7dbcb540a3 | ||
|
09a58fecd1138e6bb5bc22be0a609953 | ||
|
9e47c1abe702fd2597cb15ab4fd71f55 | ||
|
11ca0eac890eb6338a31cfaa97db95c6 | ||
|
29c72195850835532fa188b605b884b5 | ||
|
42d4999c4848911e6d6bfad4a886e993 | ||
|
59d8a1274b711d1626dd23011afb68b4 | ||
|
80eef40b16ff7458c9ba9850f128f86f | ||
|
552f404a418073a4fdbe0d05ed04378d | ||
|
677a5528d2783e640e459fcfd7346e3e | ||
|
77477bb73cbe07eac9f1cd439531b628 | ||
|
b6cbad8c6f9679cd3329dce77f542cd6 | ||
|
c031b5d4b40caa9e4cbb6c280d8f82de | ||
|
e69a8d71cec13827cccbe5fb201bb070 | ||
|
ebb634d5de705e31751cbbc1b0eb9f64 | ||
|
ef39c8f91d595f51514f3e5564625ddb | ||
|
f7c2b3c3b7cfd2a0c24bc62449b36e19 | ||
|
乐视网络电视-4.8.0.1 | ||
|
搜狗高速浏览器-2.2.0.1713 | ||
|
金长江网上交易汇智版8.3 | ||
|
Dr.Web |
0f38d469e473c2c1953a60b31839a6d4 |
静态误报4，动态误报1，总误报5 |
|
09a58fecd1138e6bb5bc22be0a609953 | ||
|
59d8a1274b711d1626dd23011afb68b4 | ||
|
d71ca20fc633bb8e856ec8e707df5869 | ||
|
迅雷7-7.1.4.2112 | ||
|
Emsisoft |
0f38d469e473c2c1953a60b31839a6d4 |
静态误报4，动态误报6，总误报10 |
|
2be0902045ec835e8b2d1b7dbcb540a3 | ||
|
42d4999c4848911e6d6bfad4a886e993 | ||
|
677a5528d2783e640e459fcfd7346e3e | ||
|
CNTV-CBox网络电视客户端-2.0.0.1 | ||
|
WinRAR4.00beta3中文版 | ||
|
光大银行阳光网盾驱动 | ||
|
搜狗高速浏览器-2.2.0.1713 | ||
|
美图秀秀2.5.7-2.5.7.1000 | ||
|
豌豆荚手机精灵1.8-1.8.121.565 | ||
|
ESET |
0f38d469e473c2c1953a60b31839a6d4 |
静态误报5，动态误报0，总误报5 |
|
2be0902045ec835e8b2d1b7dbcb540a3 | ||
|
42d4999c4848911e6d6bfad4a886e993 | ||
|
677a5528d2783e640e459fcfd7346e3e | ||
|
77477bb73cbe07eac9f1cd439531b628 | ||
|
Filseclab |
0f38d469e473c2c1953a60b31839a6d4 |
静态误报8，动态误报0，总误报8 |
|
1ae330727911ffd5f89e7ddd63ed99c6 | ||
|
2be0902045ec835e8b2d1b7dbcb540a3 | ||
|
11ca0eac890eb6338a31cfaa97db95c6 | ||
|
42d4999c4848911e6d6bfad4a886e993 | ||
|
677a5528d2783e640e459fcfd7346e3e | ||
|
77477bb73cbe07eac9f1cd439531b628 | ||
|
c031b5d4b40caa9e4cbb6c280d8f82de | ||
|
G DATA |
42d4999c4848911e6d6bfad4a886e993 |
静态误报5，动态误报0，总误报5 |
|
80eef40b16ff7458c9ba9850f128f86f | ||
|
552f404a418073a4fdbe0d05ed04378d | ||
|
e69a8d71cec13827cccbe5fb201bb070 | ||
|
ef39c8f91d595f51514f3e5564625ddb | ||
|
IKARUS |
0efc2cd726bc566415a74b4e3d2d1867 |
静态误报7，动态误报1，总误报8 |
|
0f38d469e473c2c1953a60b31839a6d4 | ||
|
2be0902045ec835e8b2d1b7dbcb540a3 | ||
|
42d4999c4848911e6d6bfad4a886e993 | ||
|
677a5528d2783e640e459fcfd7346e3e | ||
|
ebb634d5de705e31751cbbc1b0eb9f64 | ||
|
f7c2b3c3b7cfd2a0c24bc62449b36e19 | ||
|
光大银行阳光网盾驱动 | ||
|
Jiangmin |
2be0902045ec835e8b2d1b7dbcb540a3 |
静态误报2，动态误报0，总误报2 |
|
77477bb73cbe07eac9f1cd439531b628 | ||
|
Kaspersky |
11ca0eac890eb6338a31cfaa97db95c6 |
静态误报5，动态误报2，总误报7 |
|
1ae330727911ffd5f89e7ddd63ed99c6? | ||
|
42d4999c4848911e6d6bfad4a886e993 | ||
| 9e47c1abe702fd2597cb15ab4fd71f55 | ||
|
c031b5d4b40caa9e4cbb6c280d8f82de | ||
|
光大银行阳光网盾驱动 | ||
|
股市大亨-3.1.6.0 | ||
|
McAfee |
0efc2cd726bc566415a74b4e3d2d1867 |
静态误报12，动态误报0，总误报12 |
|
0f38d469e473c2c1953a60b31839a6d4 | ||
|
1ae330727911ffd5f89e7ddd63ed99c6 | ||
|
2be0902045ec835e8b2d1b7dbcb540a3 | ||
|
09a58fecd1138e6bb5bc22be0a609953 | ||
|
9e47c1abe702fd2597cb15ab4fd71f55 | ||
|
11ca0eac890eb6338a31cfaa97db95c6 | ||
|
42d4999c4848911e6d6bfad4a886e993 | ||
|
59d8a1274b711d1626dd23011afb68b4 | ||
|
677a5528d2783e640e459fcfd7346e3e | ||
|
77477bb73cbe07eac9f1cd439531b628 | ||
|
c393ef8f7f5bf8c5cf7b8001e6a2cdff | ||
|
Microsoft |
42d4999c4848911e6d6bfad4a886e993 |
静态误报2，动态误报0，总误报2 |
|
77477bb73cbe07eac9f1cd439531b628 | ||
|
Micro World |
|
静态误报0，动态误报0，总误报0 |
|
NETGATE |
0f38d469e473c2c1953a60b31839a6d4 |
静态误报3，动态误报0，总误报2 |
|
9e47c1abe702fd2597cb15ab4fd71f55 | ||
|
e69a8d71cec13827cccbe5fb201bb070 | ||
|
Panda |
0f38d469e473c2c1953a60b31839a6d4 |
静态误报4，动态误报1，总误报5 |
|
09a58fecd1138e6bb5bc22be0a609953 | ||
|
677a5528d2783e640e459fcfd7346e3e | ||
|
77477bb73cbe07eac9f1cd439531b628 | ||
|
超级兔子2011-11.0.10.0 | ||
|
Qihoo |
677a5528d2783e640e459fcfd7346e3e |
静态误报2，动态误报2，总误报4 |
|
c031b5d4b40caa9e4cbb6c280d8f82de | ||
|
<国泰期货-8.2010.430.1> | ||
|
<股市大亨-3.1.6.0> | ||
|
QuickHeal |
0f38d469e473c2c1953a60b31839a6d4 |
静态误报8，动态误报0，总误报8 |
|
1ae330727911ffd5f89e7ddd63ed99c6 | ||
|
2be0902045ec835e8b2d1b7dbcb540a3 | ||
|
8b9664c8a1e123921f6673c6e08784e2 | ||
|
11ca0eac890eb6338a31cfaa97db95c6 | ||
|
42d4999c4848911e6d6bfad4a886e993 | ||
|
80eef40b16ff7458c9ba9850f128f86f | ||
|
77477bb73cbe07eac9f1cd439531b628 | ||
|
Rising |
0f38d469e473c2c1953a60b31839a6d4 |
静态误报2，动态误报2，总误报4 |
|
11ca0eac890eb6338a31cfaa97db95c6 | ||
|
| ||
|
<光大银行阳光网盾驱动> | ||
|
SOPHOS |
0efc2cd726bc566415a74b4e3d2d1867 |
静态误报7，动态误报1，总误报8 |
|
0f38d469e473c2c1953a60b31839a6d4 | ||
|
09a58fecd1138e6bb5bc22be0a609953 | ||
|
9843f3c120b327f67ad082d0d0ab1688 | ||
|
77477bb73cbe07eac9f1cd439531b628 | ||
|
c031b5d4b40caa9e4cbb6c280d8f82de | ||
|
e69a8d71cec13827cccbe5fb201bb070 | ||
|
CITIC B2C PayGate | ||
|
Sunbelt |
0efc2cd726bc566415a74b4e3d2d1867 |
静态误报11，动态误报1，总误报12 |
|
0f38d469e473c2c1953a60b31839a6d4 | ||
|
2be0902045ec835e8b2d1b7dbcb540a3 | ||
|
09a58fecd1138e6bb5bc22be0a609953 | ||
|
9e47c1abe702fd2597cb15ab4fd71f55 | ||
|
11ca0eac890eb6338a31cfaa97db95c6 | ||
|
42d4999c4848911e6d6bfad4a886e993 | ||
|
677a5528d2783e640e459fcfd7346e3e | ||
|
77477bb73cbe07eac9f1cd439531b628 | ||
|
e69a8d71cec13827cccbe5fb201bb070 | ||
|
ef39c8f91d595f51514f3e5564625ddb | ||
|
超级兔子2011-11.0.10.0 | ||
|
Symantec |
0efc2cd726bc566415a74b4e3d2d1867 |
静态误报8，动态误报0，总误报8 |
|
2be0902045ec835e8b2d1b7dbcb540a3 | ||
|
09a58fecd1138e6bb5bc22be0a609953 | ||
|
42d4999c4848911e6d6bfad4a886e993 | ||
|
80eef40b16ff7458c9ba9850f128f86f | ||
|
677a5528d2783e640e459fcfd7346e3e | ||
|
77477bb73cbe07eac9f1cd439531b628 | ||
|
e69a8d71cec13827cccbe5fb201bb070 | ||
|
Trend Micro |
0f38d469e473c2c1953a60b31839a6d4 |
静态误报4，动态误报0，总误报4 |
|
677a5528d2783e640e459fcfd7346e3e | ||
|
77477bb73cbe07eac9f1cd439531b628 | ||
|
e69a8d71cec13827cccbe5fb201bb070 | ||
|
TrustPort |
0f38d469e473c2c1953a60b31839a6d4 |
静态误报5，动态误报0，总误报5 |
|
9e47c1abe702fd2597cb15ab4fd71f55 | ||
|
42d4999c4848911e6d6bfad4a886e993 | ||
|
77477bb73cbe07eac9f1cd439531b628 | ||
|
ef39c8f91d595f51514f3e5564625ddb | ||
|
VBA32 |
0f38d469e473c2c1953a60b31839a6d4 |
静态误报11，动态误报4，总误报15 |
|
1ae330727911ffd5f89e7ddd63ed99c6 | ||
|
2be0902045ec835e8b2d1b7dbcb540a3 | ||
|
9e47c1abe702fd2597cb15ab4fd71f55 | ||
|
11ca0eac890eb6338a31cfaa97db95c6 | ||
|
42d4999c4848911e6d6bfad4a886e993 | ||
|
653b3c557330035491672db5645d3efd | ||
|
77477bb73cbe07eac9f1cd439531b628 | ||
|
c031b5d4b40caa9e4cbb6c280d8f82de | ||
|
d71ca20fc633bb8e856ec8e707df5869 | ||
|
ef39c8f91d595f51514f3e5564625ddb | ||
|
<美图秀秀2.5.7-2.5.7.1000> | ||
|
<超级兔子2011-11.0.10.0> | ||
|
<迅雷7-7.1.4.2112> | ||
|
<金长江网上交易汇智版8.3> | ||
|
Zillya |
0f38d469e473c2c1953a60b31839a6d4 |
静态误报4，动态误报1，总误报5 |
|
2be0902045ec835e8b2d1b7dbcb540a3 | ||
|
42d4999c4848911e6d6bfad4a886e993 | ||
|
77477bb73cbe07eac9f1cd439531b628 | ||
|
腾讯QQ2011-1.60.2012.192 |
PCSL误报测试：误报测试统计表
*安天防线7为纯扫描器
PCSL误报测试：认证
5. 认证
关于PCSL
PCSL是国内唯一从事反恶意软件测试的第三方独立机构，也是国际反恶意软件测试标准组织AMTSO、亚洲反病毒研究者协会AVAR的独立会员和IEEE Malware Working Gourp的独立观察员。AMTSO著名成员包括：Virus Bulletin(VB100)、av-comparatives、avtest、West Coast Labs(西海岸实验室)、NSS Lab等权威机构与安全厂商。PCSL远景是立足中国，通过不断地创新和改良测试体系，模拟最贴近用户日常使用的计算机环境，提供可信并具备参考价值的测试报告。
PCSecurityLabs
官方网站：http://www.pcsecuritylabs.net/
PCSL误报测试：免责声明
6.免责声明
It is not permitted to extract parts from our test results and transfer them into your own tests or to use the final data without written permission from PC Security Labs. We cannot be held liable for any damage or loss, which might result from the use of information provided on our website or in our test reports. We do our best to ensure the correctness of test results, but we do not at any time provide a guaranty for the correctness or completeness of the information published on our website or in our test reports. You are allowed to download, view, print and copy the material from our site to the hard disk of your computer and use it in good faith only for your personal, non-commercial purpose as information resource. It is forbidden to transmit or re-circulate any material obtained from PC Security Labs (including from any email delivered by PC Security Labs) to any third party without our prior written consent. We focus on computer security and we do our best to try and protect PC security. All samples are gathered from the Internet. All our research is undertaken in a secure environment and to prevent any manipulation, we remove all extensions of a sample. Any commercial organization that wishes to cite findings contained in the report should contact Jeffrey on his email address (jeffrey@pcsecuritylabs.net). Any antivirus vendor may use our monthly or annual testing award logo free of charge on the Internet, on marketing material and on product packaging. For more detailed information about the annual certification, please contact Jeffrey Wu via email: jeffrey@pcsecuritylabs.net. We reserve the right of withdrawing the license of monthly award and annual certification in case of improper use by an antivirus vendor.
网友评论